Pagliai's Pizza Charleston, IL location since 1964 Pagliai's Pizza Pagliai's Pizza Dining room Pagliai's House Dressing made locally The House pizza at Pagliai's in Charleston Pagliai's Special - thin crust Pagliai's Tortelinni and Garlic Bread Pagliai's pizza Cheese Styx and sauce Pagliai's Spaghetti and Garlic Bread Poor Boy sandwich Pagliai's Pizza dining room in Charleston, IL Pagliai's Special Pizza Fresh from the oven "Pagliai's Special" pizza Thin crust cheese pizza slice slice of "The House" pizza from Pagliai's Pizza Pagliai's Cheese Styx and sauce Selection of wines Miller Lite on tap